Is Waterproof Mascara Bad for Your Eyelashes?

Estimated read time 6 min read
  Reading time 8 minutes

When it comes to eye makeup, waterproof mascara has become a go-to product for many looking to avoid smudges and maintain long-lasting wear, especially during humid weather or emotional events. However, the question often arises: “”Is waterproof mascara bad for your eyelashes?”” In short, while waterproof mascara can be worn without harmful effects, it does have the potential to damage eyelashes if not used or removed properly. This article aims to provide an in-depth look at the effects of waterproof mascara on your lashes and how to use it safely.

Composition of Waterproof Mascara

Waterproof mascaras are designed to resist moisture and last longer on the lashes as compared to their non-waterproof counterparts. The key ingredients typically include various waxes, silicones, and polymers that create a film that coats the lashes, repelling water and oils. This mixture makes sure that the product doesn’t budge, keeping your lash look intact.

  1. Waxes such as beeswax or carnauba wax provide the mascara with its thickness and enable it to stick to the lashes.
  2. Silicones like dimethicone or cyclomethicone create a smooth application and add to the product’s water-repelling properties.

Unlike regular mascara, which can run or smear when exposed to moisture, waterproof versions stand strong against tears, sweat, and rain.

Discover the truth about waterproof mascara and cancer risk - expert insights

Benefits of Using Waterproof Mascara

One of the primary advantages of waterproof mascara is its durability. It’s the perfect companion for emotional movies, workout sessions, or a long day at work where you want your eye makeup to stay put.

  • Longevity – keeping your eyes looking fresh from morning until night.
  • Resistance to elements – combating the smudges that come with rain or tears.

Such durability makes it a favorite for weddings, funerals, and hot summer days – basically, any situation where ordinary mascara would likely run or smudge. You can confidently go about your day without frequent touch-ups or concerns over raccoon eyes.

Potential Drawbacks of Waterproof Mascara

Whilst the endurance of waterproof mascara is its major selling point, this same tenacity can be troublesome for the delicate eyelashes. Routine use of these products can lead to increased lash loss due to the vigorous effort required to remove the mascara. The impact on your lashes can be significant—frequent and harsh removal can cause breakage and even potentially slow down the regeneration of the lashes.

  • Difficulty in removal, often requiring more abrasive action or stronger makeup removers, which can stress the lashes and the delicate skin around the eyes.
  • Potential for eyelash brittleness and breakage due to the drying nature of the long-wearing formula.
  • Increased risk of eyelash loss when removing the mascara or through daily wear and tear.
  • Possibility of allergic reactions for those with sensitive eyes due to some of the strong ingredients needed to make the mascara waterproof.

Proper application and gentle removal are crucial to mitigate these risks. Moreover, a break from wearing waterproof mascara now and then can allow your eyelashes to recover from any potential stress.

Is waterproof mascara better than regular? Find out which one is worth the investment.

Proper Application and Removal

To reap the benefits of waterproof mascara while minimizing potential harm, applying and removing it correctly is key. For application, start with the following steps:

  1. Begin by curling your lashes if desired, as this helps to prevent the need for over-applying mascara to achieve a curled effect.
  2. Apply the waterproof mascara in thin coats, building up slowly to avoid clumping and allowing each layer to dry in between applications.

Proper removal is arguably more important than application, as it’s during this stage that the majority of damage can occur. Here are a few tips:

  • Use a dedicated eye makeup remover designed for waterproof formulas.
  • Soak a cotton pad with the remover and gently press it against your closed eye for several seconds, allowing the remover to dissolve the mascara, reducing the need for harsh rubbing.
  • Gently wipe away the mascara in a downward motion, and if needed, use a clean cotton swab dipped in remover to carefully work on the remaining bits.

Incorporating these steps into your routine helps protect your lashes and ensures that you enjoy the benefits of waterproof mascara without the drawbacks affecting your eyelashes’ health.

Alternatives to Waterproof Mascara

In the quest for long-lasting, smudge-proof lashes without the potential risks associated with waterproof mascara, many beauty enthusiasts are turning to alternatives that are gentler on the eyes. One popular choice is water-resistant mascara, which offers some degree of staying power but is not as harsh as its waterproof counterpart. Other options include:

  1. Tubing mascaras, which create tiny tubes around each eyelash and can be easily removed with warm water and gentle pressure.
  2. Fiber mascaras that work by attaching small fibers to your lashes, extending them for a fuller look, are also easier to remove than waterproof formulas.

These alternatives provide a compromise, allowing users to achieve a durable makeup look with less risk to their eyelashes. It is still important, however, to be gentle during the application and removal process to maintain healthy lashes over time.

Is waterproof mascara difficult to remove? Expert tips for easy removal


Waterproof mascara is not inherently bad for your eyelashes, but it does demand careful use and removal to prevent potential damage. The prolonged wear and tough-to-remove nature of waterproof mascara can lead to lash loss and irritation if not managed properly. By understanding the composition of waterproof mascara and the proper application techniques, as well as exploring gentler alternatives, you can enjoy the benefits of smudge-free lashes without compromising their health. With all things in cosmetics, moderation and attentive care go a long way in ensuring that beauty enhancements do not become beauty burdens.


1. How often should I use waterproof mascara?

Limiting the use of waterproof mascara to occasions when it’s truly needed, such as during sports or a special event where tears are expected, can help minimize potential damage to your lashes.

2. Can waterproof mascara cause permanent damage to eyelashes?

While waterproof mascara is not likely to cause permanent damage, repeated and improper use can lead to temporary lash loss and breakage. Allowing time for your lashes to recover and ensuring gentle removal can prevent long-term issues.

3. Are there natural alternatives to waterproof mascara that are less harmful?

Yes, there are natural mascaras on the market that use beeswax and plant-derived ingredients to offer some water resistance without the harsh chemicals found in traditional waterproof formulations.

4. What should I do if I experience irritation from waterproof mascara?

If you experience irritation, stop using the product immediately, and if necessary, consult with a doctor or dermatologist. Switching to hypoallergenic or ophthalmologist-tested products may also help prevent future irritation.

5. How can I strengthen my eyelashes after using waterproof mascara?

Consider using a nourishing lash serum to help strengthen and revitalize your lashes. Also, giving your lashes a break from mascara from time to time can help them remain healthy.

You May Also Like

More From Author